In addition to the earlier discussion on Debate is Free this morning with the lovely Alison Thewliss there seems to be movement on the Brown bullying debacle tonight. Today Christine Pratt the Head for the National Bullying Helpline gave a statement saying that they had recieved calls from staff who worked in Downing street and although the charity was careful not to blame Brown directly. There were "problems in his department" and that inferring that the allegations was a nonsense was damaging to staff. Christine Pratt said: “Over recent months we have had several inquiries from staff within Gordon Brown's office. "Some have downloaded information; some have actually called our helpline directly and I have spoken to staff in his office."
Downing Street offered a very curt reply saying that the NBH had never contacted them about bullying and that the Civil Service had a zero tolerance approach to bullying. Not much change there then and the denials have echoes of when Brown was asked at PMQs by Tory MP Stephen Crabb about throwing printers around and bullying staff in May last year.
The National Bullying Helpline has come under some scrutiny after making the statement with it being accused of bias having a Tory patron and a number of other Tory figures in its ranks. It would seem the backlash has already begun for the NBH with a fellow charity Bullying UK calling the National Bullying Helpline's actions "disgusting".
The question is how long can this go on? With Gordon Brown being accused of having volcanic rages, screaming and swearing at staff and being borderline violent is that someone you want to throw into a hostile negotiation environment?
If the Prime Minister is doing half of what he is being accused of is the job now getting to him? And would it be kinder for him to step aside?
Sunday, 21 February 2010
Saturday, 30 January 2010
John McFall is leaving the building.
Another day and another MP announces that he won't be standing in the next General Election, which by now may only be mere weeks away. John McFall yesterday declared that he won't be standing again for re-election. However this leaves the Labour party in West Dunbartonshire with a problem. They don't have much time to select someone which means all the usual methods: picking a candidate, getting them vetted, prepping them on party policy, getting them ready to face the media on a frequent basis are going to be stretched to breaking point.
There is another option however and it is one that Labour are already doing in multiple constituencies all over Scotland: select an MSP to fight for the Westminster seat. Cathy Jamieson and Margaret Curran are now standing for Westminster and they may be joined by yet another MSP. As far as can be seen the Labour party have two choices for West Dumbartonshire and both are already MSP's. These are Des McNulty MSP for Clydebank and Milngavie or Jackie Baillie MSP for Dumbarton and shadow health minister.
Not much choice but with this little time Labour doesn't have the time it needed to be choosy.
There is another option however and it is one that Labour are already doing in multiple constituencies all over Scotland: select an MSP to fight for the Westminster seat. Cathy Jamieson and Margaret Curran are now standing for Westminster and they may be joined by yet another MSP. As far as can be seen the Labour party have two choices for West Dumbartonshire and both are already MSP's. These are Des McNulty MSP for Clydebank and Milngavie or Jackie Baillie MSP for Dumbarton and shadow health minister.
Not much choice but with this little time Labour doesn't have the time it needed to be choosy.
Tuesday, 19 January 2010
Pushing the boundary
Its one of the most ambitious projects ever undertaken by a programme on a student radio station, there are over 400 secondary schools, 21 universities , 46 colleges in Scotland and we are getting in contact with them all. Hundreds of thousands of young people across Scotland are going to be offered the chance to take part in a project thats the first of its kind in Scotland.
Debate is Free which airs only on Subcity radio at the University of Glasgow is working on a special edition of the show separate from its usual format. 2010 is a General Election year and thousands of young people will looking at the political parties on offer and wondering who to vote for. Some may never have voted either due to the fact they were too young or they have never felt the need to vote or politics leave just them cold.
Debate is Free aims to bring the debate in a way that young people will find accessible and can interact with in a way they want to.
The special edition of Debate is Free on March 11th, potentially just weeks before an election is called will bring a panel of six before a studio audience for 90 minutes to answer their questions and questions submitted by listeners. The debate will range from the topical, to party policy to anything the audience demand be answered. Nothing is barred anything can be put forward for the panel to answer. From the recession, to the war on terror, to youth issues and human rights, we will consider anything.
Anyone will be able to listen on our website www.subcity.org and comment on what they hear on the Debate is Free Facebook fan page or by using Twitter and the tag #debateisfree. We want this to be a test of social networking so please send invites to this event to all your facebook friends and tweet details and comments. You can apply to be part of the audience here or to email any potential questions or comments email debate@subcity.org.
You can follow debateisfree on Twitter and the Facebook fanpage for panellist updates.
Debate is Free which airs only on Subcity radio at the University of Glasgow is working on a special edition of the show separate from its usual format. 2010 is a General Election year and thousands of young people will looking at the political parties on offer and wondering who to vote for. Some may never have voted either due to the fact they were too young or they have never felt the need to vote or politics leave just them cold.
Debate is Free aims to bring the debate in a way that young people will find accessible and can interact with in a way they want to.
The special edition of Debate is Free on March 11th, potentially just weeks before an election is called will bring a panel of six before a studio audience for 90 minutes to answer their questions and questions submitted by listeners. The debate will range from the topical, to party policy to anything the audience demand be answered. Nothing is barred anything can be put forward for the panel to answer. From the recession, to the war on terror, to youth issues and human rights, we will consider anything.
Anyone will be able to listen on our website www.subcity.org and comment on what they hear on the Debate is Free Facebook fan page or by using Twitter and the tag #debateisfree. We want this to be a test of social networking so please send invites to this event to all your facebook friends and tweet details and comments. You can apply to be part of the audience here or to email any potential questions or comments email debate@subcity.org.
You can follow debateisfree on Twitter and the Facebook fanpage for panellist updates.
Labels:
debate,
democracy,
facebook,
general election,
Question Time,
twitter,
young people,
youth
Tuesday, 17 November 2009
Keith Vaz: Videogames Should Have Health Warnings
It’s been a hectic week in the world of videogames. With the most anticipated game of the year Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 hitting the shelves to the joy of thousands of gamers, (and retailers) world wide. The game looks set to break all records as the fastest selling game in history and looks like its going to break the previous record that Grand Theft Auto 4 set a year ago.
Modern Warfare 2 had the biggest launch day sales of a videogame ever in the UK generating £64.7 Million, beating GTA 4 which in 2008 made a paltry in comparison £39.9 million.
So in these times of economic strife a product being so successful and loved by millions should bring a bit of cheer? Unfortunately not all see Modern Warfare 2’s success as a good thing. MP Keith Vaz was one of the first to lash out at the game for a level that appears early on called “No Russian”. In it you assume the role of an undercover CIA agent who has infiltrated a Russian terrorist cell who then massacre an airport full of civilians. The player is given the choice to play the level and can skip at any time however the level does play an integral part to the games plot as becomes evident later.
The scene is shocking, but should it not be seen in context? Terrorists are not known for being merciful when targeting those they feel deserve their wrath and this game reflects that. However it has reignited the controversies that have dogged the videogame industry for years.
Keith Vaz spoke in the Daily Mail of his displeasure: "I am absolutely shocked by the level of violence in this game and am particularly concerned about how realistic the game itself looks." Mr Vaz later raised the matter in Parliament to which he was given rather short thrift by his colleagues Tom Watson and Sion Simon.
Sion Simon the minister for Culture, Media and Sport has this to say in response to Vaz’s concerns. "The clearest recommendation of the Byron Review is that content suitable for adults should be labelled as such and sold as such, that it should be an offence to sell such content to children,"
"That's the case under current law, it will be the case with the law when it changes under the Digital Economy Bill. This game the honourable gentleman refers to is a certificate 18 game, it should not be sold to children and the government's job is to make sure that adults, clearly labelled, can get what adults should be able to, and that children are not in danger of being subjected to adult content. "
Tom Watson, a former government minster also took offence at Keith Vaz and the daily mails attack on videogames and formed the group Gamers Voice. The group has grown enormously since its inception and now stands at over 14500 members on Facebook
Keith Vaz when questioned on our latest edition said videogames should carry health warnings in a similar fashion to cigarettes. Here is the full quote here: If you look to the packaging of an 18-rated videogame, it's [the size of] a tiny 10p coin. What it should be is the same as cigarettes - it should be splashed across the front: 'This has the potential to damage your health' - and that is not happening.
But is a game really that damaging to your health? Vaz insisted he was not anti videogames and that his crusade was to protect children from harmful games but in the same instance he was also unsure what videogames his own 14 year old son played. Vaz also mentioned that parents also have a responsibility for what their children view or play but does that then mean if it is found the child has an unsuitable game should the parents be punished? Would Keith Vaz be punished under such a system depending on what his son has been playing?
There is always the argument why should adults be forced to loose out when an 18 rated game is played by a child who by law should have never have been able to get hold of the game. It doesn’t look any time soon that violent games are going to be banned but the risk of a whole medium being tarred is there.
It would certainly seem that the videogame industry has an image problem though Richard Wilson CEO of TIGA doesn’t seem to think so. But when a game such as Modern Warfare 2 is met with such a hail of controversy when many violent films are praised as art in some cases, is there a case of double standards?
For every Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 there is a Portal, for every Manhunt there is a Shadow of the Colossus. It is easy to forget that videogames are a social medium that involves family, friends and people from around the world. But is that message lost in the hysteria?
Modern Warfare 2 had the biggest launch day sales of a videogame ever in the UK generating £64.7 Million, beating GTA 4 which in 2008 made a paltry in comparison £39.9 million.
So in these times of economic strife a product being so successful and loved by millions should bring a bit of cheer? Unfortunately not all see Modern Warfare 2’s success as a good thing. MP Keith Vaz was one of the first to lash out at the game for a level that appears early on called “No Russian”. In it you assume the role of an undercover CIA agent who has infiltrated a Russian terrorist cell who then massacre an airport full of civilians. The player is given the choice to play the level and can skip at any time however the level does play an integral part to the games plot as becomes evident later.
The scene is shocking, but should it not be seen in context? Terrorists are not known for being merciful when targeting those they feel deserve their wrath and this game reflects that. However it has reignited the controversies that have dogged the videogame industry for years.
Keith Vaz spoke in the Daily Mail of his displeasure: "I am absolutely shocked by the level of violence in this game and am particularly concerned about how realistic the game itself looks." Mr Vaz later raised the matter in Parliament to which he was given rather short thrift by his colleagues Tom Watson and Sion Simon.
Sion Simon the minister for Culture, Media and Sport has this to say in response to Vaz’s concerns. "The clearest recommendation of the Byron Review is that content suitable for adults should be labelled as such and sold as such, that it should be an offence to sell such content to children,"
"That's the case under current law, it will be the case with the law when it changes under the Digital Economy Bill. This game the honourable gentleman refers to is a certificate 18 game, it should not be sold to children and the government's job is to make sure that adults, clearly labelled, can get what adults should be able to, and that children are not in danger of being subjected to adult content. "
Tom Watson, a former government minster also took offence at Keith Vaz and the daily mails attack on videogames and formed the group Gamers Voice. The group has grown enormously since its inception and now stands at over 14500 members on Facebook
Keith Vaz when questioned on our latest edition said videogames should carry health warnings in a similar fashion to cigarettes. Here is the full quote here: If you look to the packaging of an 18-rated videogame, it's [the size of] a tiny 10p coin. What it should be is the same as cigarettes - it should be splashed across the front: 'This has the potential to damage your health' - and that is not happening.
But is a game really that damaging to your health? Vaz insisted he was not anti videogames and that his crusade was to protect children from harmful games but in the same instance he was also unsure what videogames his own 14 year old son played. Vaz also mentioned that parents also have a responsibility for what their children view or play but does that then mean if it is found the child has an unsuitable game should the parents be punished? Would Keith Vaz be punished under such a system depending on what his son has been playing?
There is always the argument why should adults be forced to loose out when an 18 rated game is played by a child who by law should have never have been able to get hold of the game. It doesn’t look any time soon that violent games are going to be banned but the risk of a whole medium being tarred is there.
It would certainly seem that the videogame industry has an image problem though Richard Wilson CEO of TIGA doesn’t seem to think so. But when a game such as Modern Warfare 2 is met with such a hail of controversy when many violent films are praised as art in some cases, is there a case of double standards?
For every Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 there is a Portal, for every Manhunt there is a Shadow of the Colossus. It is easy to forget that videogames are a social medium that involves family, friends and people from around the world. But is that message lost in the hysteria?
Tuesday, 3 November 2009
Scientists versus Politicans
The problem with being interested in politics and current affairs is this nasty habit it has of never stopping. It might be a slow news day but you can bet that somewhere in the world there is something of interest going on.
Which is why I am still up at quarter to one on a Tuesday morning after doing research into the Professor Nutt sacking debacle. It's caused some amount of disquiet and it looks like its going to get uglier as the week goes on. Two other members of the ACMD, (Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs) have resigned in protest and more may follow. It's scientists on one side and politicians on the other.
For those who might not have been following the case here is a bit of background. Professor David Nutt, (who works both at the University of Bristol and Imperial College, London) last week gave a lecture at Imperial College stating both alcohol and tobacco were more deadly than many illegal drugs. You can also read his paper on the subject here.
Days later Professor Nutt was rather unceremoniously sacked by an email from Home Secretary Alan Johnson. Ouch.
Alan Johnson's decision sparked off fighting both within the government as well as out as Lord Drayson: the science and innovation minister who has overall responsibility for all scientific advice given to the government went nuclear at being left out and initially sided with Professor Nutt. One email message read "Alan did this without letting me know and giving me a chance to persuade him it's a big mistake. Is Gordon able to get Alan to undo this? As 'science champion in Government', I can't just stand aside on this one."
Unfortunately for David Nutt this stance didn't last long and Lord Drayson sided with the Government after Prime Minister Gordon Brown stepped into the fray stating that he had received reassurances from Alan Johnson and that his earlier response had been an initial reaction.
But is there any truth to what Professor Nutt says? Well lets look at some statistics for deaths in Scotland and see what it looks like.
In Scotland there were 574 drug-related deaths in 2008, but we need to be careful as these figures also include alcohol as a drug but strangely not tobacco, cannabis or LSD.
Breaking that figure down makes it appear like this:
Heroin/Morphine-336
Methadone- 181
Total of all Benzodiazepine related deaths- 364
Diazapam- 317
Temazapam- 12
Cocaine- 79
Ecstasy- 7
Amphetamines- 12
Alcohol- 273
Unfortunately as far as I can find there are no similar figures regarding tobacco related deaths for 2008 so we have to make do with 2004.
In 2004, there were almost 13,500 smoking-related deaths in Scotland - over 1 in 5 of all deaths.
That would make it appear however that David Nutt is vindicated and that deaths related to Alcohol and Tobacco vastly outweigh deaths due to drugs. With that in mind and the fact that and advice given to a government is never free lets take a look at how much the ACMD has cost for advice that was ultimately ignored. Here is a parliamentary question from last year regarding the committee's finances.
So in total the ACMD has cost the taxpayer well over half a million pounds over 5 years if my rather poor maths skills are right. That's a lot of money for a group of advisors whose advice and recommendations you are going to ignore...
Perhaps after being very public in his outburst Professor David Nutt should have expected a very public response that might have been as embarrassing to him as his recommendations were to the government. Rest assured we will be working to have him on the show and ask him personally over the next couple of weeks.
Which is why I am still up at quarter to one on a Tuesday morning after doing research into the Professor Nutt sacking debacle. It's caused some amount of disquiet and it looks like its going to get uglier as the week goes on. Two other members of the ACMD, (Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs) have resigned in protest and more may follow. It's scientists on one side and politicians on the other.
For those who might not have been following the case here is a bit of background. Professor David Nutt, (who works both at the University of Bristol and Imperial College, London) last week gave a lecture at Imperial College stating both alcohol and tobacco were more deadly than many illegal drugs. You can also read his paper on the subject here.
Days later Professor Nutt was rather unceremoniously sacked by an email from Home Secretary Alan Johnson. Ouch.
Alan Johnson's decision sparked off fighting both within the government as well as out as Lord Drayson: the science and innovation minister who has overall responsibility for all scientific advice given to the government went nuclear at being left out and initially sided with Professor Nutt. One email message read "Alan did this without letting me know and giving me a chance to persuade him it's a big mistake. Is Gordon able to get Alan to undo this? As 'science champion in Government', I can't just stand aside on this one."
Unfortunately for David Nutt this stance didn't last long and Lord Drayson sided with the Government after Prime Minister Gordon Brown stepped into the fray stating that he had received reassurances from Alan Johnson and that his earlier response had been an initial reaction.
But is there any truth to what Professor Nutt says? Well lets look at some statistics for deaths in Scotland and see what it looks like.
In Scotland there were 574 drug-related deaths in 2008, but we need to be careful as these figures also include alcohol as a drug but strangely not tobacco, cannabis or LSD.
Breaking that figure down makes it appear like this:
Heroin/Morphine-336
Methadone- 181
Total of all Benzodiazepine related deaths- 364
Diazapam- 317
Temazapam- 12
Cocaine- 79
Ecstasy- 7
Amphetamines- 12
Alcohol- 273
Unfortunately as far as I can find there are no similar figures regarding tobacco related deaths for 2008 so we have to make do with 2004.
In 2004, there were almost 13,500 smoking-related deaths in Scotland - over 1 in 5 of all deaths.
That would make it appear however that David Nutt is vindicated and that deaths related to Alcohol and Tobacco vastly outweigh deaths due to drugs. With that in mind and the fact that and advice given to a government is never free lets take a look at how much the ACMD has cost for advice that was ultimately ignored. Here is a parliamentary question from last year regarding the committee's finances.
Home Department
Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs: Finance
James Brokenshire: To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how much her Department spent to support the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs in each of the last five years. [223151]
Mr. Coaker [holding answer 10 September 2008]: The Home Office allocated the following sums of money in each of the last five years to support the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs:
Sum allocated to the ACMD (£)
2003-04 £80,000
2004-05 £135,000
2005-06 £165,000
2006-07 £152,000
2007-08 £152,800
In addition the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs secretariat staff and other civil servant costs have not been allocated as such costs are subsumed within normal salaried remuneration and within existing budgets.
29 Sep 2008 : Column 2314W
So in total the ACMD has cost the taxpayer well over half a million pounds over 5 years if my rather poor maths skills are right. That's a lot of money for a group of advisors whose advice and recommendations you are going to ignore...
Perhaps after being very public in his outburst Professor David Nutt should have expected a very public response that might have been as embarrassing to him as his recommendations were to the government. Rest assured we will be working to have him on the show and ask him personally over the next couple of weeks.
Sunday, 1 November 2009
Upcoming guests
Here is the list or our upcoming guests over the next wee while so you can get your questions and comments in. Please note a date for airing for all the interviews have not yet been confirmed.
Jim Murphy- Secretary of State for Scotland
Iain Gray- Scottish Labour Leader
Annabel Goldie- Scottish Conservative Leader
Tavish Scott- Scottish Liberal Democrats Leader
Shami Chakrabarti- Director of Liberty
Vince Cable- Liberal Democrat Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer
Keep your comments coming in!
Jim Murphy- Secretary of State for Scotland
Iain Gray- Scottish Labour Leader
Annabel Goldie- Scottish Conservative Leader
Tavish Scott- Scottish Liberal Democrats Leader
Shami Chakrabarti- Director of Liberty
Vince Cable- Liberal Democrat Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer
Keep your comments coming in!
Saturday, 31 October 2009
This weeks show
Come on all you politics buffs. We have a Glasgow North East special coming up this Sunday; the party campaigns are in their final days as we approach polling day on November 12th.
We have an interview with Tommy Sheridan the co-leader of Solidarity and candidate in Glasgow North East. As well as short interviews with Willie Bain where we ask him after Labour being in power in Glasgow North East how do they defend their record in the city and the constituency? Ruth Davidson, what should happen to MP's such as Derek Conway, Should they be prosecuted? And Eileen Baxendale, what happened at the Lib Dem conference this weekend and will they support an independence referendum in the future?
We will have the SNP's David Kerr, the Green's David Doherty, and the SSP's Kevin McVey on next week.
So tune in to hear us live tomorrow (Sunday) morning from 0945-1030 only on http://www.subcity.org/listen.
You can interact with the show while its on air by Studio: 0141 341 6222 / debate@subcity.org Studio SMS: "subcity" followed by message to 07766 40 41 42
Or contact us anytime by posting on the blog or emailing debate@subcity.org.
We have an interview with Tommy Sheridan the co-leader of Solidarity and candidate in Glasgow North East. As well as short interviews with Willie Bain where we ask him after Labour being in power in Glasgow North East how do they defend their record in the city and the constituency? Ruth Davidson, what should happen to MP's such as Derek Conway, Should they be prosecuted? And Eileen Baxendale, what happened at the Lib Dem conference this weekend and will they support an independence referendum in the future?
We will have the SNP's David Kerr, the Green's David Doherty, and the SSP's Kevin McVey on next week.
So tune in to hear us live tomorrow (Sunday) morning from 0945-1030 only on http://www.subcity.org/listen.
You can interact with the show while its on air by Studio: 0141 341 6222 / debate@subcity.org Studio SMS: "subcity" followed by message to 07766 40 41 42
Or contact us anytime by posting on the blog or emailing debate@subcity.org.
Thursday, 29 October 2009
Debate is Free interviews Tommy Sheridan
This week we will be interviewing Tommy Sheridan co-leader of Solidarity as part of Debate is Free's series on the party leaders in Scotland. Sheridan has had a controversial and colourful past especially in the past couple of years. The former MSP has been jailed three times in the past once for his opposition against the Poll tax and twice for his protests against Trident at Faslane Naval Base.
Tommy is one of the most recognisable politicians in Scotland and the UK and makes numerous appearances across the country. Tommy Sheridan has been a councillor for the city of Glasgow, MSP and recently stood to be an MEP in the European elections this year.
He has also appeared on Celebrity Big Brother and at the Edinburgh Fringe
We will be talking to Tommy Sheridan as he is on the campaign trail in Glasgow North East so get your questions in quickly before 4pm today (29th October) either to the blog page or via email on debate@subcity.org.
Check us out here http://www.subcity.org/shows/debateisfree/
Spread the word about Debate is Free and join in.Got a point to make then email debate@subcity.org or while the show is on air or contact us on the following Studio: 0141 341 6222 Studio SMS: "subcity" followed by message to 07766 40 41 42
Tommy is one of the most recognisable politicians in Scotland and the UK and makes numerous appearances across the country. Tommy Sheridan has been a councillor for the city of Glasgow, MSP and recently stood to be an MEP in the European elections this year.
He has also appeared on Celebrity Big Brother and at the Edinburgh Fringe
We will be talking to Tommy Sheridan as he is on the campaign trail in Glasgow North East so get your questions in quickly before 4pm today (29th October) either to the blog page or via email on debate@subcity.org.
Check us out here http://www.subcity.org/shows/debateisfree/
Spread the word about Debate is Free and join in.Got a point to make then email debate@subcity.org or while the show is on air or contact us on the following Studio: 0141 341 6222 Studio SMS: "subcity" followed by message to 07766 40 41 42
Labels:
Party leaders,
Scotland,
Scottish Parliament,
Solidarity,
Tommy Sheridan
Tuesday, 27 October 2009
Labour's Cabinet Reshuffle
It’s been a bit of a muted day on the politics front on this rather dreich day. But there has been one thing of interest. There was a shadow cabinet reshuffle of Scottish Labour. With the now former education spokeswoman Rhona Brankin being booted out perhaps it is the curse of an education brief biting and Brankin not being seen as effective in tackling the SNP’s Education Minister Fiona Hyslop.
Iain Gray issued the following statement regarding her departure.
"Rhona has taken Fiona Hyslop to task as the worst education minister since devolution began, with broken promises on class sizes, school buildings and teacher numbers."
Though considering that out of the six education ministers there has been since devolution began back in 1999 and that Fiona Hyslop is the first to be non Labour perhaps it pays to be cynical as to why Gray would be calling her the worst out of the lot.
The new shadow cabinet is as follows;
Iain Gray- Leader
Johann Lamont- Deputy Leader
Cathy Jamieson- Housing and Regeneration
Jackie Baillie- Health Spokeswoman
Andy Kerr- Finance and economy
Michael McMahon- Local government spokesman
John Park- Elections and campaigns
Des McNulty- Education
Paul Martin- Parliament Business Manager
Richard Baker- Justice
Sarah Boyack- Environment & Rural Affairs
Pauline McNeill- Culture and Constitution
David Stewart- Chief Whip
Both Jackie Baillie’s and Cathy Jamieson’s new appointments are both very interesting.
Jackie Baillie has been very prominent on attacking the SNP on the C diff outbreak at the Vale of Leven Hospital. However there are still a lot of unhappy constituents in Dumbarton who remember who axed A&E services at the Vale and Baillie is sure to come under fire once more now she is charge of health for the shadow cabinet.
Cathy Jamieson taking over the housing brief may indicate that Labour see Alex Neil, the SNP’s Housing and Communities Minister as more as a threat than they let on if Jamieson is to take him on in future.
Iain Gray issued the following statement regarding her departure.
"Rhona has taken Fiona Hyslop to task as the worst education minister since devolution began, with broken promises on class sizes, school buildings and teacher numbers."
Though considering that out of the six education ministers there has been since devolution began back in 1999 and that Fiona Hyslop is the first to be non Labour perhaps it pays to be cynical as to why Gray would be calling her the worst out of the lot.
The new shadow cabinet is as follows;
Iain Gray- Leader
Johann Lamont- Deputy Leader
Cathy Jamieson- Housing and Regeneration
Jackie Baillie- Health Spokeswoman
Andy Kerr- Finance and economy
Michael McMahon- Local government spokesman
John Park- Elections and campaigns
Des McNulty- Education
Paul Martin- Parliament Business Manager
Richard Baker- Justice
Sarah Boyack- Environment & Rural Affairs
Pauline McNeill- Culture and Constitution
David Stewart- Chief Whip
Both Jackie Baillie’s and Cathy Jamieson’s new appointments are both very interesting.
Jackie Baillie has been very prominent on attacking the SNP on the C diff outbreak at the Vale of Leven Hospital. However there are still a lot of unhappy constituents in Dumbarton who remember who axed A&E services at the Vale and Baillie is sure to come under fire once more now she is charge of health for the shadow cabinet.
Cathy Jamieson taking over the housing brief may indicate that Labour see Alex Neil, the SNP’s Housing and Communities Minister as more as a threat than they let on if Jamieson is to take him on in future.
Thursday, 22 October 2009
The BNP and Question Time
As you know there is nothing Debate is Free likes more than a good passionate discussion on the things that matter and what has people getting fired up. So as you can imagine I have been watching the furore over the BNP being invited to Question Time with a great deal of interest over the past few weeks.
The BNP is full of the worst of our society, it can boast of rapists, murderers, paedophiles and a range of thugs in its membership. All suited and polished in order to adhere to the party’s recent family friendly make-over.
But no amount of polish can hide what the BNP really stand for and what they seek to do to this country if they ever got the chance.
One of the BNP’s beliefs is that the holocaust was a hoax and that Hitler in words of Nick Griffin the BNP’s leader, "went a bit too far".
Well its nice to know that the murders of Jews, Communists, trade unionists, the disabled, gays and lesbians, gypsies and a variety of people who proved to be inconvenient to the Third Reich totalling 17 million massacred in death camps and the deaths of over 50 million people worldwide was just going a bit too far.
Then there is also the delightful misogyny of a Mr Nick Eriksen; a former BNP London Assembly candidate and party organiser for London, who in his blog wrote the following regarding rape.
"I've never understood why so many men have allowed themselves to be brainwashed by the feminazi myth machine into believing that rape is such a serious crime ... Rape is simply sex. Women enjoy sex, so rape cannot be such a terrible physical ordeal.
"To suggest that rape, when conducted without violence, is a serious crime is like suggesting force-feeding a woman chocolate cake is a heinous offence. A woman would be more inconvenienced by having her handbag snatched."
Charming. But this is what you can expect from Mr Eriksen and others like him in the BNP, despite the fact that he was removed from the BNP’s London Assembly list for his comments, many senior figures rallied around him saying his comments were “taken out of context”. So as long as that man at the bar you say no to in the first place adds some rohypnol to your drink while your back is turned before dragging you off to a quiet spot to get his way rape is a-ok. As long as you are not beaten black and blue that makes rape condonable in the eyes of Eriksen and his ilk.
But these are not the worst of the BNP, for that you have to look to David Copeland, now also known as the London Nail Bomber. In 1999 Copeland was responsible for the deaths of three people including a woman expecting her first child and the injuries of nearly 130 people, four of whom lost limbs. A toddler also had a nail embedded in the brain which required extensive surgery to remove.
In the end the BNP were not tough enough for Copeland so he joined the Neo-Nazi group, the National Socialist Movement. A group known for their extreme violence and desire to terrorise the UK’s Asian, Black, Gay and Jewish communities.
I could go on, but to be honest I could be here for days listing the convictions and faults of BNP members both past and present.
Whether you like the BNP or not they should be allowed on Question Time tonight. To refuse them sets a dangerous precedent that could be abused against other smaller parties when they say or do things that the three big parties don’t like. Are we now going to stop the Green party who also hold two seats in the European Parliament speaking out on controversial issues?
Hysterical screaming will not make the BNP go away, they must be taken on face to face with both rational debate and serious action. To try and hide them makes them appear like martyrs for their cause and underdogs in the political process.
The BNP are capitalising on the failures of successive governments and their failure to address the fears of a large proportion of the population be they unfounded or not. Fear is the most corrosive emotion; it makes normally rational people lash out against the things they don’t understand. And what people are scared of now is the unknown, do they have jobs tomorrow, will their children have jobs in the future. There are many people out there who are scared that now the world is going too fast for them to keep up with.
But there are also those who understand what the BNP really are and support it. I have the suspicion that the UK is not nearly as enlightened as it likes to think it is. With more hate crimes reported than ever before are we now fooling ourselves into thinking that the BNP’s support are simply frightened of the future rather than people who support the BNP’s racist policies?
But as for would Debate is Free ever interview Nick Griffin? Yes, we would. Its time for someone to ask questions of the BNP’s leader. Questions like; does the BNP still believe that ethnic minorities should be sterilised? What happens to the voluntary removal of immigrants and anyone with the wrong colour of skin when they refuse to move? Will they be forced out the country? What will happen to the children of mixed-race couples? Will the marriages of mixed race couples be nullified?
These questions need asked, and chances are it’s not going to happen on this night’s edition of Question Time, but its time to see what Griffin is saying and start fighting against him.
The BNP is full of the worst of our society, it can boast of rapists, murderers, paedophiles and a range of thugs in its membership. All suited and polished in order to adhere to the party’s recent family friendly make-over.
But no amount of polish can hide what the BNP really stand for and what they seek to do to this country if they ever got the chance.
One of the BNP’s beliefs is that the holocaust was a hoax and that Hitler in words of Nick Griffin the BNP’s leader, "went a bit too far".
Well its nice to know that the murders of Jews, Communists, trade unionists, the disabled, gays and lesbians, gypsies and a variety of people who proved to be inconvenient to the Third Reich totalling 17 million massacred in death camps and the deaths of over 50 million people worldwide was just going a bit too far.
Then there is also the delightful misogyny of a Mr Nick Eriksen; a former BNP London Assembly candidate and party organiser for London, who in his blog wrote the following regarding rape.
"I've never understood why so many men have allowed themselves to be brainwashed by the feminazi myth machine into believing that rape is such a serious crime ... Rape is simply sex. Women enjoy sex, so rape cannot be such a terrible physical ordeal.
"To suggest that rape, when conducted without violence, is a serious crime is like suggesting force-feeding a woman chocolate cake is a heinous offence. A woman would be more inconvenienced by having her handbag snatched."
Charming. But this is what you can expect from Mr Eriksen and others like him in the BNP, despite the fact that he was removed from the BNP’s London Assembly list for his comments, many senior figures rallied around him saying his comments were “taken out of context”. So as long as that man at the bar you say no to in the first place adds some rohypnol to your drink while your back is turned before dragging you off to a quiet spot to get his way rape is a-ok. As long as you are not beaten black and blue that makes rape condonable in the eyes of Eriksen and his ilk.
But these are not the worst of the BNP, for that you have to look to David Copeland, now also known as the London Nail Bomber. In 1999 Copeland was responsible for the deaths of three people including a woman expecting her first child and the injuries of nearly 130 people, four of whom lost limbs. A toddler also had a nail embedded in the brain which required extensive surgery to remove.
In the end the BNP were not tough enough for Copeland so he joined the Neo-Nazi group, the National Socialist Movement. A group known for their extreme violence and desire to terrorise the UK’s Asian, Black, Gay and Jewish communities.
I could go on, but to be honest I could be here for days listing the convictions and faults of BNP members both past and present.
Whether you like the BNP or not they should be allowed on Question Time tonight. To refuse them sets a dangerous precedent that could be abused against other smaller parties when they say or do things that the three big parties don’t like. Are we now going to stop the Green party who also hold two seats in the European Parliament speaking out on controversial issues?
Hysterical screaming will not make the BNP go away, they must be taken on face to face with both rational debate and serious action. To try and hide them makes them appear like martyrs for their cause and underdogs in the political process.
The BNP are capitalising on the failures of successive governments and their failure to address the fears of a large proportion of the population be they unfounded or not. Fear is the most corrosive emotion; it makes normally rational people lash out against the things they don’t understand. And what people are scared of now is the unknown, do they have jobs tomorrow, will their children have jobs in the future. There are many people out there who are scared that now the world is going too fast for them to keep up with.
But there are also those who understand what the BNP really are and support it. I have the suspicion that the UK is not nearly as enlightened as it likes to think it is. With more hate crimes reported than ever before are we now fooling ourselves into thinking that the BNP’s support are simply frightened of the future rather than people who support the BNP’s racist policies?
But as for would Debate is Free ever interview Nick Griffin? Yes, we would. Its time for someone to ask questions of the BNP’s leader. Questions like; does the BNP still believe that ethnic minorities should be sterilised? What happens to the voluntary removal of immigrants and anyone with the wrong colour of skin when they refuse to move? Will they be forced out the country? What will happen to the children of mixed-race couples? Will the marriages of mixed race couples be nullified?
These questions need asked, and chances are it’s not going to happen on this night’s edition of Question Time, but its time to see what Griffin is saying and start fighting against him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
